10 Best Sandwich Makers To Buy in 2023

Comment author avatar
S.A. Yanes Modified: September 4, 2023
10 Best Sandwich Makers To Buy in 2023

We’ve all been there — rushing out the door with a badly-made sandwich on one hand during a busy morning. Luckily, such an unfortunate scenario is avoidable, as long as you have the best sandwich maker sitting on your kitchen counter.

If you often find yourself in a hurry, then breakfast makers such as a sandwich press, toasters or toastie makers, and a panini press deserve a spot on your countertops. On the other hand, you can recreate a satisfyingly good Chick-fil-A-inspired spicy chicken sandwich that’s loaded with mouthwatering fillings using a handy sandwich maker.

To help you choose among the staggering number of breakfast makers available on the market today, we narrowed down the options for you. We’ve considered essential factors including handy features and overall quality. Explore our favorite picks below, as well as some buying tips in case you decide to venture into the delicious world of sandwiches.

Our Favorite Sandwich Makers At A Glance

10 Best Sandwich Makers For Better Mornings

With a quality sandwich maker within your reach, you get to savor perfectly made sandwiches even amidst your busiest schedule. Hence, we peered into the best sandwich makers available on the market and cherry-picked the most impressive ones. Here are our top favorites in terms of special features and overall quality:

1. Best Overall: Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker

What We Love

  • Easy to use
  • Efficient
  • Easy to clean

What We Don't Love

  • Not ideal for large sandwiches

With its impressive ratings and thousands of reviews on Amazon, this kitchen equipment proves to be efficient when it comes to making breakfast sandwiches.

In a time crunch? No worries! This winning sandwich maker from Hamilton Beach lets you enjoy a belly-filling Italian-grilled cheese recipe in just a few minutes. What’s even better is that with this grilled cheese sandwich maker, you can cook the bread, egg, cheese, and other tasty fillings all at once! All you have to do is add the bottom of your sandwich, then the pre-cooked meat or veggies and cheese on the bottom layer. On the next layer, give the sandwich a cheesy spin by incorporating slices of Swiss cheese before finally topping it with the top muffin. Set the timer for five minutes and you’re good to go!

Furthermore, this product is also equipped with indicator lights. This feature lets you know if the equipment is hot enough before you toss the ingredients onto the plates or if the muffins are well done. If you have a small kitchen space, this compact sandwich will work best for you as well. It also features removable and non-stick parts, making the cleanup so much easier.

Slicing or grating cheese for your favorite sandwich snack can be a daunting task. Make it easier using these 12 Best Cheese Graters For Cheese Lovers.

2. Best Budget-Friendly: Cuisinart WM-SW2N1 Grill Sandwich Maker

What We Love

  • Affordable
  • Versatile
  • Lock-down lid
  • Light indicators

What We Don't Love

  • Can be small for some

If you want to grab a bite of a delicately made sandwich but don’t want to break your budget, then this Cuisinart sandwich maker is the best machine to get. It may carry a value price tag but this tool has many practical features too.

One of the main selling points of this product is its versatility in the kitchen. With this convenient tool, you can press sandwiches, grill omelettes, and even crisp a sweet French toast recipe as well. And you can even cook two servings all at once!

Moreover, this product also has a lock-down lid, ensuring that both sides of the sandwich are cooked evenly. There are also raised ridges in the cooking plates to seal in the ingredients and to divide the sandwiches for easy slicing. This equipment also comes with dual indicators lights that serve as a signal for you whether it’s the right time to put the foodstuffs on the grill or when the meal is fully done.

3. Best for Families: Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Timer

What We Love

  • Can cook two sandwiches at once
  • Easy to clean

What We Don't Love

  • Foodstuff may leak out and get stuck behind the handles

Packed with practical features, this dual breakfast sandwich maker from Hamilton Beach is another efficient sandwich machine available on the market today.

This model, which is the bigger version of the Hamilton Beach sandwich maker, is suitable for whipping up two custom sandwiches at once. And it can have your breakfast ready in a matter of minutes! The fact that you can cook yummy meals including English muffins, biscuits, and even a Cheddar avocado bagel using this machine makes it even better.

When it comes to cleaning this equipment, you don’t have to worry as you can simply toss the removable parts in the dishwasher. This product also comes with quick and easy recipes for you to try and enjoy with your loved ones.

4. Most Easy Clean: Chefman Electric Panini Press Grill and Gourmet Sandwich Maker

What We Love

  • Versatile
  • Nonstick cooking plates
  • Light indicators
  • Easy to clean

What We Don't Love

  • Doesn’t have temperature control

It’s no wonder that customers are raving about this product as it combines the functions of a press and a grill in a single device.

What’s even better is that with just a touch of a button, you’ll be enjoying customized sandwiches in no time! This equipment also features an adjustable floating hinge and a closed cooking surface that can accommodate different sizes of sandwiches. Craving some succulent sloppy joe recipe? Well, this tool opens flat at 180° for grilling burgers, veggies, and even steaks!

With its compact size, storing this product won’t be an issue. Plus, it’s easy to carry around so it’s ideal to bring on summer picnics and road trips. This machine also has tilt-up rubber feet which allow the grease from your food to drain into the back of this closed panini sandwich maker. It also features nonstick coated grill plates and a removable drip tray, making it easier to clean when you’re done for the day.

Furthermore, you can also browse through its downloadable user guide which includes some tips on how to use this machine, as well as a few recipes for you to try at home.

5. Best For Grilling/Best Sandwich Grill: Ovente Electric Indoor Sandwich Grill Maker

What We Love

  • Multipurpose
  • Nonstick cooking plates
  • Heat-resistant

What We Don't Love

  • Emits oily smell

This may appear like a regular sandwich grillmaker at first glance, but there’s nothing basic about this product in terms of functionality and quality.

One thing to love about this machine is that doesn’t take long before it fully heats up. In addition to that, you can also simultaneously cook two sandwiches at the same time, thanks to its deep-pocketed cooking plates. This kitchen device is also well-loved for its faster and even heat distribution. So, rest assured that no part of your sandwich will be left uncooked or overcooked when you use this product.

And when it comes to safety, this product does not fall behind as it has anti-skid feet. This feature ensures that the appliance will remain in place as you cook. It’s also made with premium quality stainless steel, so it’s definitely resistant to heat, corrosion, and rust.

Lastly, a noticeable and impressive feature of this machine is its nonstick plates. Finished with a high-grade coating, rest assured that no foodstuff will stick onto the plates. Best of all, this product can do so much more than just create custom sandwiches! It’s also largely useful for cooking sunny-side-ups, Portobello mushroom omelettes, and toasties. This machine is light and portable, making it suitable for outdoor trips.

6. Most Versatile: Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill with Locking Lid

What We Love

  • Versatile
  • Nonstick grills
  • Light indicators

What We Don't Love

  • Has a short product life

If you’re looking for a sandwich maker that does more than one function, then look no further than this electric panini press grill from Hilton Beach! Not only is this ideal for a panini sandwich, but it’ll also be useful should you want to try your hand at some chicken quesadillas and more.

This device features a floating lid that presses either thin or thick sandwiches. The top lid lock, on one hand, lets you create a filling creamy bruschetta or any open-faced sandwiches. Moreover, there’s no need to flip the sandwich as the top and bottom grids can already heat and brown this scrumptious treat. This product also has light indicators that’ll turn green if it’s time to toss the ingredients onto the grills. As it has non-stick grills, you can easily wipe off the dirt with a soaked cloth after use.

7. Best Nonstick: Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker

What We Love

  • Nonstick coating
  • Cool-touch locking handle
  • Compact and portable

What We Don't Love

  • Can be too small for some

This top-quality cookware is backed by almost 5,000 rave reviews for its affordability and other special features.

In less than five minutes, your sandwich cravings will be satisfied. There are also light indicators, letting you know whether or not your favorite snack is ready to eat. With its diagonal indentation, you’ll end up with four perfectly toasted mini sandwiches. This machine is also armed with a cool-touch locking handle for added safety. Plus, it’s also portable and compact, which makes it easier to store.

This equipment has an ultra-non stick cooking surface which is even further strengthened by ceramic and titanium materials. With this characteristic, there’s no need to butter up the plates when you cook some mini bacon cheeseburgers. Love a hassle-free cleanup? You’ll be glad to know that its nonstick coating prevents any foodstuff from sticking onto the plates. As it’s compact and portable, this product suits any kitchen space. It’s also constructed to last for years and is secured by a one-year warranty.

8. Best Stovetop: BulbHead Copper Flipwich Non-Stick Grilled Sandwich and Panini Maker

What We Love

  • Copper-infused ceramic cooking surface
  • Rust-resistant
  • Lightweight

What We Don't Love

  • Might break easily if not handled carefully

Convenience is one of this product’s strongest suits. For one thing, this cooking equipment lets you flip hot sumptuous sandwiches easily. Plus, its aluminum induction plates allow even heat distribution, ensuring that you’ll end up with a yummy cheese panini recipe.

This product also features two interlocking grill pans and a copper-infused ceramic cooking surface. It’s finished with a non-stick coating and is resistant to rust as well. Moreover, this machine is roomy enough so you can incorporate your preferred fillings between the bread. However, you should figure out the ideal heat setting on your stovetop burners. This basically depends on whatever dish you’re cooking.

Portable and lightweight, this stovetop panini maker is easy to carry around and store. And when you purchase this product, you’ll also get fun and creative recipe ideas from the booklet that comes with it.

9. Best Compact: OSTBA Sandwich Maker

What We Love

  • Easy to carry around
  • Multipurpose
  • Cool-touch handle

What We Don't Love

  • A bit flimsy

Many satisfied customers love this high-quality cookware for its cute and compact size. Despite its small size, this product boasts stellar reviews and high ratings on Amazon.

With its easy-to-carry structure, it’s suitable for tiny kitchens and can be conveniently stored upright. This product is also ideal for backyard picnics. In terms of efficiency, this machine is top-notch as it lets you have a hot sandwich in no time. Moreover, its efficacy also extends to grilling a nutritious chicken omelette and making your French toast extra crispy.

This kitchen equipment also includes indicator lights and a cool-touch handle to ease out worries of getting scalded or messing up. Its non-stick plates are also commendable as they ensure hassle-free cleanup.

10. Best Smart Features: Breville BGR820XL Smart Grill

What We Love

  • Features an element IQ technology
  • Three temperature settings
  • Two cooking modes
  • Adjustable height setting

What We Don't Love

  • Difficult to clean

Featuring an element IQ technology, this Breville sandwich grill is our best pick among all sandwich makers with smart features.

With its three temperature settings, six adjustable height settings, and two modes (one for panini and another for barbecue), this smart grill proves its efficiency in the kitchen. All of those aforementioned features make this indoor grill suitable for pressing sandwiches, searing meat, and even grilling vegetables. In its barbecue mode, this machine opens flat to give you two cooking surfaces. You can pick whether you want to grill some real good ribs barbeque on either the ribbed plate or the flat plate. There’s also a drip tray to catch the drippings from the seared meat. In its panini mode, on the other hand, simply tilt the base to drain fat.

Looking for mouthwatering barbecue dishes to serve at your next backyard party? Check out our article on What Are Rib Tips & Riblets and Ways to Cook Them.

This product, however, comes with a less-than-affordable price tag. It’s worth the splurge, though, because of its impressive quality and functionality.

What To Look For in a Sandwich Maker

close-up view of a sandwich maker

Flickr | Ivan Radic

With all the sandwich makers out there in the market, choosing the best one can be confusing for some. Now, to help you make a final purchase decision, here are some key factors that you should consider:


Generally, there are numerous types of sandwich makers and each is built for different purposes. And the two most common types are the panini press sandwich makers and four triangle sandwich makers.

The panini machine is convenient for grilling different foods such as meats and veggies. Meanwhile, the four triangle sandwich maker is armed with square-shaped heating plates and is constructed to hold up to bread slices. Nevertheless, both types are efficient in making delicious sandwiches. 

This kitchen essential also comes in either electric or stovetop types. If you want a machine that is convenient, flexible, and time-saving, opt for the electric-powered sandwich makers. In terms of functionality, some models are perfect for layered sandwiches and some are ideal for egg sandwiches. Always go for the one that best suits your needs and lifestyle!

Size and Capacity

Have a relatively small kitchen? Then compact sandwich makers are an excellent option as they’re way easier to store. As sandwiches are best enjoyed with your loved ones, large-sized machines also make for an incredible choice as well. They can cook up to four sandwich slices at once!

Cook Setting

Regular sandwich makers usually include only one cook setting while high-end ones feature more than three settings. This specific quality lets you adjust the heat or the cooking method depending on the food you’re cooking. Ideally, the more cooking settings, the better as you’re more likely to end up with evenly cooked meals.

Safety Features

This is also an important factor to consider when purchasing this kitchen device. The ones with fully enclosed griddles or cooking plates and cool-touch handles are safer to use as they minimize accidental burns. You should also check if the product has non-slip feet to prevent it from sliding off when you’re using it.

Other vital features such as indicator lights are also crucial factors to consider. This component alerts you when the machine has already reached the ideal temperature or when your sandwich is ready to serve.

Read Next: 7 Best Chefman Air Fryer Models To Try

S.A. Yanes

S.A. Yanes is a fiction writer, poet, book blogger, and content editor. At Recipes.net, she writes food ingredient guides, product reviews, and more. Prior to that, she has worked in a publishing house and was the brand manager of an up-and-coming writing and reading online platform. She has written numerous short fictions as well as engaging bible stories for children. She's also a certified foodie with an immense love for anything cheesy and chocolatey.